The financial life cycle of a professional footballer - Planning for retirement
Part 2 - Planning for retirement
Published 16 June 2014 | Authored by: Sam Sloma Anna Moore Robin Charrot
Planning for retirementAfter a player has bought his first property, what is likely be his main residence, and is earning what may be considered a “good income” as he moves into the peak years of his career, attention turn to other aspects of his life such as investments, pensions and protection of assets.
The annual personal allowance is currently £40,000 (tax year 14/15) and every member of the Football League gets £4,750 per year from the PFA for each year were under contract.2
This means players can place £35,250 per tax year into a pension. The actual contribution needed to max out this contribution is £28,200 (as the government will give them the £7,050 difference in tax relief). This then equates to a saving of £2,350 per month net. They will then be entitled to a rebate in tax for the additional 20% or 25% depending on their earnings.
For those earning £20,000 per month net of tax or over this shouldn’t be a problem. This figure provides for a large monthly mortgage repayment, one or two cars, bills etc. Therefore they may only have approx. £5,000 left per month to save.
However what proportion of savings would you want to allocate to age 35 and how much to age 55? Bearing in mind the players cannot touch the pension funds and, as stated previously, at the age of 35 any earnings will be significantly less than their football earnings. This is when a player will need the money the most. Therefore it is not wise for a player to tie all their savings up until age 55. It is sensible for players to plan to save for the medium term (to age 35) and for the long term (age 55).
Individual Savings Accounts (ISA’s);
£5940 of this can be put into a cash ISA and the rest into stocks and shares or the full £11,880 into stock and shares fully. This is rising to £15,000 on July 1st 2014.
Sensible players maximise their ISA allowances every year. If they are married they can use their wife’s allowance if they are already maximising their own allowance. Quite quickly they can build up tax free sums that are readily available should they need them.
General Investment Account
If growth can be kept to under £10,900 there is no tax to pay. Every year a player can take out the £10,900 and place it a ISA.
This means the ISA contribution will come from tax free money, which is extremely tax efficient.
Buy to let
Elite professionals with earnings in the upper echelons of football and buying multiple properties should consider buying through companies. Any money withdrawn can be taken as a dividend which is more tax efficient than paying at their marginal rate of 45%. If no money is withdrawn, only corporation tax is payable at 20%. Directors can also pay someone, in some instances a family member, to manage their portfolio through the corporate structure.
The major issues for a player are the same as with buying a main residence: the effective management of the properties. There have been instances where players have bought properties that have been left empty for three months, meanwhile the player is still paying for utilities. Whilst this may not be considered “big money” if a player has three or four properties, it can still accumulate into an significant amount of expenditure being paid on an empty flat.
The perception of property portfolios is that they are easy to build. The reality is that it is very difficult for a player to manage unless they have a team around them and good organisational skills. Players also need to think of tax implications on their income and should always inform their accountant as mistakes can lead to costly fines from HM Revenue & Customs.
Film Schemes, Overseas Property Investments, etc.
Protection of assets
Pre and Post nuptial agreements
A growing feature of society in general and in professional sports is the prenup agreement. UK law does recognise them10, and although the divorce court has the ultimate say on how finances will be split on divorce, a well drafted prenup which meets the wife’s reasonable needs will have heavy influence over the court’s decision.
Ideally the prenup should be signed at least four weeks before the wedding and the negotiations should start with lawyers on both sides, a few months before the wedding.
Prenups do not state, ‘I’ll keep all of my money and you’ll have nothing as I’ve earned everything’. They are about protecting certain assets, or setting a much lower limit for capital and maintenance payments than the divorce court would use. They provide certainty and security to the player and their wife. They are about finding a solution when the relationship is good and both partners are happy and will be reasonable with each other.
If there is no prenup, and if a sportsperson or his wife were caught cheating, it could (quite rightly) cause a large degree of hostility. Trying to sort out division of assets and payment of maintenance when both sides are very angry will be far harder.
The cost of a prenup is dependent on the complexity of the situation but it will always be far cheaper (far less than a tenth) than the cost of dealing with finances on divorce if a couple does not have one.
If the player was married before they had any significant money, and they do not have a prenup, they should consider a postnup, which provides the same function as a prenup.
Introducing the idea of a prenup or a postnup is not romantic, and not very easy. However, there are ways of doing it which will not cause offence. Lawyers who are specialists in this area can advise on how to successfully ‘sell’ the idea of a prenup or postnup.
A cohabitation agreement has the same influence as a prenup or a postnup and plays the same role (limiting claims against the player, providing financial security for their girlfriend). The cost of a cohabitation agreement will also be far less than the cost of reaching a settlement after the relationship has broken down.
If a person dies without a Will, there are set rules which dictate who will get what11. If the deceased person has a spouse he/she would get everything but if the person was not married to their partner, he/she will get nothing. If the deceased had a spouse and children, the spouse would get the personal belongings, a lump sum of £250,000 and half of the remaining assets (from October 2014, following a change in the law)12. The children would get the other half of the remaining assets once they became adults. If the deceased does not have a spouse or children, the deceased’s assets would pass according to a set list set out by law. The parents would take everything if they are alive and, if not, the brothers and sisters and so on, to the more distant relatives if necessary. There is no flexibility in these provisions and the deceased’s estate may not pass according to their wishes.
If a person takes proper advice on an appropriate Will, this document can not only make sure that the correct people benefit under the Will but can also deal with the following:
- Who should administer the estate?
- Who should act as guardians of any children?
- Who should receive personal belongings or any cash gifts?
- Any funeral wishes?
A Will can also include provisions to protect wealth, often by the use of ongoing trusts. An individual could grant their spouse an automatic right to income (with the option to give him/her lump sums of capital in the future) but in the meantime, the capital is protected for the children or other beneficiaries. If the individual is making provision for children, a trust could ensure that they receive their ‘share’ at an appropriate age rather than automatically at a set age (usually 18, 21 or 25). Provision could be made for a partner, while making sure that some of the wealth is preserved for the individual’s family.
A couple of examples show how this protection can work in different ways:
A young wealthy footballer marries and has two children. He unfortunately passes away in a motoring accident and his Will leaves his entire estate to his wife. She remarries a few year later and has another child. On her death, her estate passes to her new husband, who eventually passes most of the wealth to his own child rather than to the two children of the footballer. This could have been prevented had the wife only been given a right to income, with the capital of the footballer’s wealth protected for the eventual benefit of his own children.
Another wealthy footballer marries and has two children. He dies at a time when his children are 16 and 17 and he has no will. Under the intestacy provisions, his two children are entitled to a proportion of his estate automatically when they reach the age of 18. One of the footballer’s children reaches the age of 18 and receives her share. It is clear to everyone that she is far too young to manage such a large amount of money but the law doesn’t allow for her entitlement to be postponed. She has a great time spending her money over the next few years but has little left by the age of 30 and no steady job prospects. If her inheritance had been put into a trust structure, the assets could have been preserved until such time as she was mature enough to handle them on her own, while being used for her maintenance in the meantime.
Career ending insurance;
The policies take medical reports from club doctors and analyse the risk on pre existing and previous injuries. Generally a policy will allow two years’ worth of rehabilitation treatment before a player can decide, on medical advice that he won’t be able to continue with his career.13 Payments are made free of tax to the player and can help a player to continue a career during life after football.
Life and Critical Illness Cover
Life insurance pays out a tax free sum to named beneficiaries if something were to happen to the insured. Critical illness cover does the same if the insured were to have a serious illness. They usually run to 55/60/65 and are there to pay a mortgage if someone were to pass away prior to it being paid off.
With life assurance, rather than leaving funds directly to the individuals who are intended to take the benefit, it is often good planning to direct the policy proceeds into a fully discretionary trust. The terms of such trusts can be very flexible, with players able to choose a body of individuals (the Trustees) to manage the funds on behalf of the beneficiaries. The funds can be available for the use of the chosen beneficiaries in a variety of flexible ways but in the meantime, the funds are not added to their estates for the calculation of inheritance tax. Crucially the use of a trust structure can also provide valuable protection against issues such as remarriage (for a spouse or partner), divorce and/or financial weakness or inexperience. A trust can be brought to an end if it isn’t needed but can be very valuable in certain circumstances.
Critical illness policies differ from provider to provider. It is important that advisers check policy wordings and make sure clients are going for the most comprehensive cover, rather than the cheapest premium.
The premiums are paid monthly and are calculated out on mortality and morbidity rates respectively. The health of the individual and immediate family members is also taken into consideration.
Usually young, fit, professional athletes can get cover for extremely low premiums. These are level in cover and so if a player takes out cover at a younger age, the premiums will remain low for the lifetime of the policy.
Players can always get additional cover in later years but there will be no point in cancelling the cheapest policy. This is a good planning tip.
The Full Circle
The agent, manager, lawyer, financial adviser are still vital cogs in a retired players machine. Players need to explore options, build a plan, read through contracts, negotiate and look after their assets.
From a financial point of view, cash flow modelling is important. A cash flow model details every aspect of a player’s financial position and can inform on what income needs to be received, what level of tax the player will pay, what return is needed to be generated on the invested funds and how to plug any shortfalls.
It can factor in selling of homes, children’s school fees, holidays etc to really help in the planning process. Without the security of the three year contract, which is familiar occurrence for most players, the need for planning becomes far greater.
Ideally players should aim to build up assets to allow them the time to make independent decisions on their future. The funds built up during a playing career provide players with options to explore new career paths and most importantly secure financial security for them and their families once their profession has ended.
3. The New ISA – Frequently Asked Questions, HMRC.gov.uk, viewed 10 June 2014, https://www.hmrc.gov.uk/isa/new-isa-faq.pdf
4. Introduction to Capital Gains Tax, HMRC.gov.uk, last viewed 10 June 2014, https://www.hmrc.gov.uk/cgt/intro/basics.htm#5
5. H Glass, ‘Film funding tax scheme abuse may be costing HM Revenue & Customs ‘£5bn at least’, This is Money, 21 June 2102, viewed 04 June 2014, https://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/news/article-2162591/K2-tax-scheme-Film-funding-tax-scheme-abuse-risking-inland-revenue-5bn-least.html
6. The Other Side of Football’s Coin- Divorce, Dysfunction and Depression. Peter Staunton, 11 March 2014, viewed 10 June 2014. https://www.goal.com/en/news/1717/editorial/2014/03/11/4674611/the-other-side-of-footballs-coin-divorce-dysfunction-and
7. Monaco football club's owner must pay £2.6 billion in World record divorce settlement – Don Mackay, 30 May 2014, viewed 10 June 2014 https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/monaco-football-clubs-owner-must-3573473
8. Van der Vaart Splits from Model Wife 21 May 2014, viewed 10 June 2014. https://msn.foxsports.com/foxsoccer/championsleague/story/rafael-van-der-vaart-splits-with-model-wife-sylvie-admits-to-domestic-abuse-010213
9. Cheryl’s £4m Ash Cash Joy, 5 June 2010, viewed 1- June 2014 https://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/showbiz/bizarre/3001163/Cheryl-Cole-to-get-45m-from-Ashley-in-divorce-settlement.html
10. A whole string of cases leading up to, and following on from, the 2010 Supreme Court case of Radmacher v Granatino https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-11580907
11. Administration of Estates Act 1925
12. Inheritance and Trustees’ Powers Act 2014
13. An example of such a policy from the insurance company Lockton (https://www.lockton.com/) states:
“We offer a 24-month claim notification period which means a player can be declared Permanently Totally Disabled (Career Ended) at any stage within 24 months of the original Accident or Sickness.”
This work was written for and first published on LawInSport.com (unless otherwise stated) and the copyright is owned by LawInSport Ltd. Permission to make digital or hard copies of this work (or part, or abstracts, of it) for personal use provided copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage, and provided that all copies bear this notice and full citation on the first page (which should include the URL, company name (LawInSport), article title, author name, date of the publication and date of use) of any copies made. Copyright for components of this work owned by parties other than LawInSport must be honoured.
- Tags: Athlete Welfare | Contract Law | Employment Law | Financial Regulation | Football | Image Rights | Insurance | Intellectual Property | Pensions | Player Contracts | Player Representation | Scholarships | United Kingdom (UK) | Wills
- The financial life cycle of a professional footballer - The early years
- Pre-Contracts in football
- Image rights companies in football – where are we now?
- The reality of "Life after Sport"