Moore & Bertuzzi officially reach an agreement: NHL violence avoids spotlight for now
Published 11 September 2014 By: Joseph M. Hanna
The decade long legal battle between Todd Bertuzzi and former Colorado Avalanche player Steve Moore is officially at rest.
After confusing reports1 of a potential settlement between Moore and Bertuzzi surfaced about two weeks ago, they were quickly undermined2 by Steve Moore’s brother,3 Mark, claiming the deal was a farce to pressure Steve into settling.
The allegations were finally ended on Thursday, however, when Steve Moore released an official statement leaving no suspicion or doubt: “the legal case for the loss of my NHL career is over. I have accepted a settlement4 agreement which has now been finalized and signed by all the parties.” As was anticipated, the amount was not disclosed, nor will it likely ever be.
Moore’s lawsuit arose from a career-ending sucker punch he received on ice from Todd Bertuzzi, a member of the Canucks, back in March of 2004. A few weeks prior, Moore landed a questionable body-check on Vancouver’s Captain, Markus Naslund, giving him a concussion. Vancouver players publicly spoke out about Moore, calling him a marked man.
On March 8, the teams met again, and Todd Bertuzzi threw a devastating right hook to the back of Moore’s head after Moore refused to turn and face him. As Moore crashed to the ice unconscious, Bertuzzi, fell on top of his back while many others, from both teams, piled on. Moore sustained a concussion and three cracked vertebrae, and never played in the NHL again.
Moore was injured in his rookie season, having only played 69 games in the NHL. He sought lost earnings from the NHL career he anticipated having. Originally, Moore demanded $38 million, but increased the amount of damages to $68 million this past July.
Todd Bertuzzi pleaded guilty to assault charges after the incident, avoiding jail time. He was placed on probation and performed 80 hours of community service. The NHL suspended Bertuzzi for the remaining 13 games of the season in addition to the NHL playoffs that year. He has since played 9 seasons in the NHL and is currently an unrestricted free agent.
The settlement here is potentially very significant considering the current wave of concussion-related litigation running rampant throughout professional and collegiate sports. The NHL has several recent lawsuits pending, which have been consolidated US District Court in Minnesota.
Commissioner Gary Bettman, team owners, and other executives would’ve been called to testify had this matter gone to trial, exposing the NHL’s handling of concussions and the violence causing them. While the NHL’s unique policy toward violence would’ve come under heavy scrutiny in this trial, it will stay out of the spotlight for now, until the concussion litigation moves forward.
As happy as Moore and Bertuzzi may be the case is over, the NHL must be ecstatic to put this matter to rest before the concussion litigation makes its way to the bench. 5
This work was written for and first published on LawInSport.com (unless otherwise stated) and the copyright is owned by LawInSport Ltd. Permission is granted to make digital or hard copies of this work (or part, or abstracts, of it) for personal use provided copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage, and provided that all copies bear this notice and full citation on the first page (which should include the URL, company name (LawInSport), article title, author name, date of the publication and date of use) of any copies made. Copyright for components of this work owned by parties other than LawInSport must be honoured.
- Tags: Canada | Concussion | Criminal Law | Ice Hockey | National Hockey League (NHL) | Player Welfare | United States of America (USA)
- Canadian health organizations’ call for concussion protocols to protect those participating in high risk sports
- American football helmet maker Riddell attempts to dismiss class action concussion suit
- Sports governing bodies and player welfare: examining the proposed NFL and NCAA concussion settlements
- Concussion awareness, crowd trouble, and European deal signed