Regulating unruly football fans: the state of English law and proposed improvements
In scenes reminiscent of football’s darker days 7 March 2015 saw two pitch invasions1 at Villa Park. The first took place in stoppage time when a small number of Villa fans ran onto the pitch, forcing referee Anthony Taylor to halt the game. This group were persuaded to remove themselves from the pitch by the mass booing from the remaining fans, the urging of the players and for some the actions of stewards. They did not return to the stands but instead lined the edge of the pitch, braced to return after the final whistle.
Sure enough Taylor’s signal to end the game was also the signal for a mass pitch invasion. The early group were this time joined by thousands more with stewards helpless against the onslaught. Fans made a beeline for the players who were trying to make it to the tunnel. Fabian Delph, Villa’s captain and one of the goal scorers described it as‘dangerous, my arm band got nicked, someone tried to take my boot off my feet, people tried to kiss me and they were biting me, it was crazy’.2 If this was the reaction to a “hero” of the game, one can only imagine what West Brom players experienced as they tried to make their way to the tunnel. Police and stewards focussed their limited resources on dividing West Brom fans and Villa fans. Lest it should be said that only Villa fans were responsible, there were also reports of West Brom fans ripping up seats and throwing them onto the pitch.
Both West Brom and Aston Villa are co-operating with the FA investigation into the incident. A number of arrests have been made and it is expected that more will follow after a review of all the footage available.
Villa has now been charged3 with failing to ensure that no spectators or unauthorised persons were permitted to encroach onto the pitch.
Other recent incidents
Anyone who has had half an eye on the news in recent days, weeks and months will know that the events at Villa Park are not isolated incidents of disorder by English football fans. Examples have included:
- The racist chanting by Chelsea fans on the Paris métro after that team’s first leg tie with Paris Saint-Germain.5 There are allegations of more racist chanting by Chelsea fans on a London to Manchester train soon after Chelsea’s victory in the League Cup on 1 March 2015, in which police were called to the train as it arrived at Stoke station.6
- Reading FC has been charged7 in relation to a pitch invasion at the Madejski Stadium during their sixth-round FA Cup tie with Bradford City (the same charge Villa faces).
- A Watford FC fan suffered life-threatening injuries after that team’s draw with Wolverhampton Wanderers on 7 March 2015.8 A thirteen-year old Wolves fan has been arrested in connection with that attack.9
- On 28 February, serious violence broke out in the stands between Rotherham and Millwall fans. The police had to enter the stadium to quell the situation, which included the throwing of missiles.10
- In November, up to one hundred hooligans were involved in violent disturbances after the Manchester derby, which involved the throwing of bottles, chairs and a flare.11
Get access to this article and all of the expert analysis and commentary at LawInSport
Already a member?
Articles, webinars, conference videos and podcast transcripts
This work was written for and first published on LawInSport.com (unless otherwise stated) and the copyright is owned by LawInSport Ltd. Permission is granted to make digital or hard copies of this work (or part, or abstracts, of it) for personal use provided copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage, and provided that all copies bear this notice and full citation on the first page (which should include the URL, company name (LawInSport), article title, author name, date of the publication and date of use) of any copies made. Copyright for components of this work owned by parties other than LawInSport must be honoured.
- Tags: Banning Orders | Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 | England | FA Rules and Regulations of the Association Season 2014-2015 | Football | Football (Offences) Act 1991 | Football Spectators Act 1989 | Governance | Occupiers’ Liability Act | Order (Football (Offences) (Designation of Football Matches) Order 2004 (SI 2004_2410) | Premier League | Public Order Act 1986 | Regulation | The FA
- Discussion on Football Banning Orders with Prof Mark James and Kevin Carpenter - Episode 18
- The flexibility of sanctions under the 2015 WADA Code
- A guide to England’s Independent Football Ombudsman
- “Wild West” or “Brave New World”? The new FIFA and FA Intermediaries Regulations
- Does the FA strike the right balance on players’ and managers’ media comments?
Grahame is a barrister at Littleton Chambers and a member of Littleton’s Sports Law Group. In addition to sports law, he specialises in employment and commercial work.
Lydia is an active member of the Littleton Chambers Sports law group. In line with the broader chambers specialisms Lydia’s core areas of practice are commercial law and employment law. Lydia’s commercial practice encompasses disputes including contractual interpretation, professional negligence and directors’ duties. Lydia’s employment work has a particular focus on disability discrimination but also incorporates all areas of tribunal disputes and high court action in relation to bonuses and restrictive covenants.