Sports investigations: the risky business of deleting phone apps
The UK’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) recently failed in its bid to prosecute Konstantin Vishnyak, a former banker, for deleting his WhatsApp messages in relation to an insider dealing investigation. The criminal prosecution, which was brought under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (FSMA), failed because the FCA could not prove that Mr. Vishnyak intended to conceal from the investigator facts disclosed by the messages.
Despite the failure of this prosecution and the fact it was brought under FSMA, it serves as an important reminder of the severe consequences that sportspersons could face if they delete messages or otherwise seek to obstruct an investigation. Indeed, whereas defendants (including sportspersons) subject to criminal prosecution for the destruction of evidence will usually be able to rely on a lack of intent as a defence (as Mr. Vishnyak did), sportspersons being prosecuted by their sporting body may find themselves in a more vulnerable position due to the general absence of a requirement for intent to be proved in order for the prosecution to succeed. This article examines:
- The Vishnyak prosecution
- The wider trend of prosecuting persons for destroying evidence
- Application to sports investigations
- Key lessons for athletes
Continue reading this article...
Already a member? Sign in
Get access to all of the expert analysis and commentary at LawInSport including articles, webinars, conference videos and podcast transcripts. Find out more here.
- Tags: Cricket | Criminal | FIFA | FIFA Code | Football | Fraud | International Cricket Council (ICC) | Investigations | NFL | Rugby | Tennis | Tennis Anti-Corruption Program | World Rugby Regulations
- A guide to Germany’s new criminal law against betting fraud and match-fixing in sports
- Italian tax: the continuing investigations into agents’ fees paid by football clubs (2020 update)
- More than just a number: how India is trying to tackle age fraud in sports
- Cyber threats to sports organisations (and key steps to reduce exposure)
About the Author
Wayne is one of the founding members of Fulcrum and has been supporting corporate clients with international law compliance and regulatory issues since 2010.
He has conducted internal investigations, designed compliance programmes, and acted as defence counsel in relation to a wide variety of white-collar crime and regulatory issues, including money laundering, bribery and corruption, tax evasion, sanctions breaches, accounting irregularities, and breaches of FCA regulations, amongst others.