The Basketball Arbitral Tribunal’s policy on publishing written reasons – does it strike the right balance between speed & legal certainty?
On March 8, the first ever User Conference of the Basketball Arbitral Tribunal (BAT) was hosted in Munich, Germany. Wouter Janssens, founding partner at international boutique sports law firm CRESTA, participated in a round table discussion to tackle several topics from over a decade of BAT practice.
One of the key subjects discussed was the BAT’s policy on publishing written reasons when issuing awards. It’s an important matter to consider as written reasons can help to explain the Arbitrator’s thinking, allowing legal practitioners to analyse awards, deduce the general legal principles applied by the Arbitrator, and comprehend the decision in the context of underlying jurisprudence. On the other hand, written reasons imply higher arbitration costs (on average € 3,930 - three thousand, nine hundred and thirty Euros - for awards without, versus € 8,963 for awards with written reasons) and an extended duration of the proceedings1.
Continue reading this article...
Already a member? Sign in
Get access to all of the expert analysis and commentary at LawInSport including articles, webinars, conference videos and podcast transcripts. Find out more here.
- Tags: Arbitration | Basketball | Basketball Arbitral Tribunal (BAT) | BAT Rules | Dispute Resolution | Federal Supreme Court of Switzerland | Regulation | Swiss Private International Law Act (PILA)
- Current developments in the Chinese sports law market 2018/19
- A cautionary tale for arbitrators in sports law disputes – lessons from Fleetwood Wanderers v AFC Fylde
- Litigation privilege hammered? Key points for sports organisations on the scope of litigation privilege from the West Ham Stadium case
Founding Partner, CRESTA
Wouter is a founding partner at CRESTA, international boutique sports law firm based in Brussels (www.crestafirm.com).
Sports lawyer representing players, agents, clubs, leagues and investors on contractual, contentious (FIFA, FIBA, FIVB, CAS, BCAS) and regulatory matters.
Attorney-at-law at the Brussels Bar and Assistant Professor of Law at the University of Leuven.