How CAS Deals With ‘Lis Pendens’ (Cases Filed Simultaneously In A National Court)
What happens if the same legal issue, involving the same parties, are simultaneously filed in both a sports arbitral court and a national civil court? Generally, this legal issue is known as ‘lis pendens’, and in the context of international sports arbitrations context, it has been raised in ten decisions published by the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS)  - although the panel only fully scrutinized the issue in three of them.
The most recent of those cases is Club Al Arabi SC v. Ashkan Dejagah (2019/A/6626), which concerned a dispute over compensation due under a prematurely terminated player contract that was filed in both the Qatar Civil Courts (by the club) and FIFA Dispute Resolution Chamber (by the player). This article analyses the case as it relates to lis pendens and the broader question of how CAS panels have approached the issue. Specifically, it looks at:
- The general definition of lis pendens
- The regulations on lis pendens applicable to CAS proceedings
- What constitutes "serious reason" / "substantive grounds”?
- Key points from the Club Al Arabi SC v. Ashkan Dejagah decision
- Lessons for practitioners
Continue reading this article...
Already a member? Sign in
Get access to all of the expert analysis and commentary at LawInSport including articles, webinars, conference videos and podcast transcripts. Find out more here.
- Tags: CAS Code | Court of Arbitration for Sport | Dispute Resolution | FIFA Dispute Resolution Chamber | Football | Lis Pendens | Qatar Football Association | Swiss Private International Law Act (PILA)
- The jurisdiction of CAS in domestic football disputes – a potential pitfall
- A data analysis of the arbitrators, cases and sports at the Court of Arbitration for Sport
- What is an independent and duly constituted National Dispute Resolution Chamber in football?
- Why Challenges Remain For US Women’s Soccer After Equal Pay Deal
- How FIFA Tribunals Are Assessing Covid-19 Force Majeure Disputes (Hiddink v Maldives F.A.)
- Why Did The Royal Spanish Football Federation Get Fined For Releasing A Zoom Recording?
Amir Arsalan Eskandari is a sports law counsel in Iran and co-founder of a boutique sports law firm (Spoleg) in Iran. Spoleg is the first Iranian law firm with an exclusive focus on sports law which is operating at both national and international levels.